The Court Explains – Forensic Evidence at fault – Amanda Knox Case

Meredith Kercher: Court explains Amanda Knox acquittal

Amanda Knox in Perugia, Italy
Amanda Knox was cleared of the murder of British student Meredith Kercher in Perugia
Lack of motive and faulty evidence led to the acquittal of Amanda Knox, an Italian court has said.

Knox, 24, saw her conviction for the murder of UK student Meredith Kercher overturned on appeal in October.

The court said in a 144-page document that forensic evidence used to support the original verdicts was unreliable.

Miss Kercher, 21, from south London, was murdered in 2007 in the house she shared with American student Miss Knox in the Italian city of Perugia.

Also acquitted of the murder on appeal was Miss Knox’s former boyfriend, the Italian Raffaele Sollecito.

Case ‘gave way’

The court said the forensic evidence could not ultimately prove the couple were at the scene of the crime on the night of the murder.

It pointed to what it said were flaws in collecting forensic evidence and testing DNA traces originally linked to the defendants.

The prosecutors’ case could not stand, the court added.

The document said: “The bricks of that building just gave way. It’s not just a case of reassembling the bricks… but rather a lack of the necessary material for the construction.”

Referring to a motive, it said: “The sudden choice of two young people, good and helpful to others, to commit evil for evil’s sake, without any further reason, seems even more incomprehensible (if it is) to support the criminal act of a young man they had no relation to.”

In Italy, courts have to publish a document to explain the reasoning for reaching a verdict.

Book deal

Miss Knox was originally sentenced to 26 years in prison and Mr Sollecito to 25 years. The pair have always denied being at the Italian home of Leeds University student Miss Kercher at the time of the murder.

The judge upheld Miss Knox’s conviction for slander after she accused bar owner Patrick Diya Lumumba of carrying out the killing.

The sentence for that was set at three years, time that Miss Knox had already served.

Miss Knox has returned to her hometown of Seattle in the US, and is looking to sign a deal to write a book about her experiences.

Rudy Guede, an Ivorian, was found guilty and sentenced to 16 years’ jail in a separate trial.

He is now the only person serving time for the murder although prosecutors said he could not have killed Miss Kercher by himself.



So from that report we can say that she MAY have still committed the Murder but due to the Forensic Evidence being recovered in an inappropriate way we will never know. You will recall there were reports of a bra clasp not being sealed for 45 days and the officers laughing and joking on the video of them working within the scene. 

Totally inappropriate behaviour. We all like to bring humour into our work, especially when the work is traumatic in nature (such as a murder), it’s a human way of coping… but there are times and places for that behaviour, and on video, in the scene is totally wrong.

Also the motive… needs to be clear when convicting in the first place.


Don’t forget to catch us on Twitter later today for #cclivechat, discussing cold cases, fingerprint recovery and many more themes… Noon EST (4pm GMT), look for the tag #cclivechat or follow me @TriniCSI

Share this Post